What are the key lessons learned about pricing from building Homestar?

Dan Lesley learned several critical lessons about pricing while building Homestar. One major realization was the danger of undervaluing solutions, which can attract price-sensitive clients who may not appreciate the product's core value. Additionally, he found that a complex pricing structure confused both the sales team and customers. Finally, the importance of adjusting prices to reflect product evolution and properly communicating value in relation to market dynamics became clear over time.

How did undervaluing the solution affect client perceptions?

Undervaluing the solution led to attracting clients who were primarily price-sensitive, which diminished their appreciation of the value offered by Homestar. This misalignment resulted in a customer base that did not fully understand or benefit from the core offerings. Ultimately, it compromised the company's market positioning and hindered growth, as the business struggled to convey the significant value inherent in its services.

What challenges did the pricing complexity create for the sales team?

The complex pricing structure created numerous challenges for the sales team at Homestar. They struggled to explain the various tiers, discounts, and custom plans to prospects, leading to confusion and frustration among potential clients. This complexity hindered effective sales conversations, often leaving prospects unsure of what value they were getting for the price, which negatively impacted conversions and overall sales performance.

What mistake was made in the approach to international pricing?

The one-price-fits-all strategy tried when expanding internationally was a significant mistake for Homestar. It failed to account for the different competitive dynamics and varying willingness to pay in each market. This oversight resulted in lost deals in price-sensitive regions and missed opportunities to maximize revenue in other markets, highlighting the need for tailored pricing strategies that are sensitive to local market conditions.

Why is customer feedback on pricing important for a business?

Customer feedback on pricing is crucial for any business, as it provides insight into client perceptions and value assessments. Ignoring this feedback, as Dan Lesley initially did, can lead to misunderstandings about how pricing affects customer retention. Listening to customers helps businesses identify potential concerns that may affect loyalty, thus guiding necessary adjustments to pricing strategies and ensuring better alignment with their customers' needs and expectations.

How did technology influence pricing strategies negatively for Homestar?

Technology and data-driven algorithms initially influenced Homestar's pricing strategies, but they often failed to capture important market nuances and relationship dynamics. By overly relying on pricing software, the company missed critical human insights that seasoned sales professionals could identify. This disconnection led to suboptimal pricing decisions that did not accurately reflect the realities of the market, ultimately necessitating a reevaluation of how to balance data with human judgment.

What have been the long-term benefits of reevaluating Homestar's pricing strategy?

Reevaluating Homestar's pricing strategy has led to long-term benefits by creating a more sustainable approach that aligns better with client needs and market conditions. This shift has allowed the company to communicate value effectively, improve customer satisfaction, and reduce churn rates. Ultimately, the lessons learned from past pricing missteps have enabled Homestar to enhance profitability and cultivate stronger relationships with its clients.

5 Mistakes I've made in B2B pricing

02 Jan 2025

Explore common pricing missteps in B2B and learn how to avoid them. Let's improve your pricing strategy together.

Today’s advice post is by Dan Lesley, Founder of Homestar. Dan has over 20 years building, growing, and selling SaaS tech startups.

"Pricing isn't just about numbers; it's about clearly communicating value and understanding the market."

Dan Lesley

Founder, Homestar

Setting prices in B2B has been one of the trickiest parts of building Homestar. After years of fumbling through different approaches and making plenty of expensive mistakes, I’ve learned some hard lessons about what works and what doesn’t.

My biggest blunder with Homestar was seriously undervaluing our solution. We got caught up in that classic startup fear of pricing too high and ended up attracting price-sensitive clients who never really appreciated the core value we provided. Looking back, those low initial prices undermined our positioning in the market.

The pricing maze we created early on still makes me cringe. We had this ridiculously complex system of tiers, discounts, and custom plans that even our sales team struggled to explain. Turns out clients just want to understand what they’re paying for without needing a spreadsheet to decode it.

The whole “one-price-fits-all” strategy we tried when expanding Homestar internationally was pretty naive. Each market has its own competitive dynamics and willingness to pay - something we learned the expensive way when we lost deals in price-sensitive regions while leaving money on the table in others.

Customer feedback about pricing used to go straight into my mental “nice to have” file. Big mistake. When our churn rate spiked and exit interviews kept mentioning price concerns, I stubbornly stuck to our model. Should’ve paid attention to those early warning signs.

Offer too much customization too quickly
Forget to reassess pricing as the product evolves
Let technology dictate pricing strategies

The customization trap caught me off guard with my previous SaaS venture. We tried being everything to everyone right out of the gate, offering endless pricing permutations. All it did was confuse prospects and complicate our sales process unnecessarily.

Product evolution at Homestar brought higher development and support costs, but our pricing stayed frozen in time. We kept adding valuable features without adjusting prices to reflect the improved offering. Rookie mistake that hurt our margins.

While data and algorithms help inform pricing decisions, I learned they can’t capture everything. The pricing software we relied on missed crucial market nuances and relationship dynamics that experienced sales folks pick up instantly. Finding that balance between data insights and human judgment took time.

Building Homestar has taught me that pricing isn’t just about numbers - it’s about properly communicating value and understanding market dynamics. These lessons weren’t cheap, but they’ve helped shape a more sustainable approach to pricing that better serves both our business and our clients.

5 Mistakes I've made in B2B pricing

Recommended Posts

The First 18 Months: Key Decisions That Shaped Our Growth Curve

Why a key first startup hire should be customer success

Why Your Co-Founder Should be a Marketer